Under the Magnifying Glass: Easy-to-Ignore Groups and Outreach STEM Education – Part 1

Going there instead of overlooking – how previously unreached target groups can be reached with MINT offerings

The photo has a decorative function. It shows three children sitting at a table. The left covers its eyes, the middle covers its ears, the right covers its mouth. It says "Part 3" in the lower left corner.
Photo: Keren Fedida on Unsplash

classification

Securing skilled workers in the STEM field is a key challenge. In order to master these, we have to inspire and qualify young people for STEM subjects. There is still a lot of untapped potential here. For example, children and young people who, for various reasons, have not yet found access to (MINT) educational opportunities.

We would like to take a closer look: Who are these groups of young people whose potential is (can) be easily overlooked? Which factors play a role? Which terms are used? And how do offers have to be tailored to reach this group(s)?

In the first part of this article, an approximation of the term "Easy-to-ignore groups“ (“Easily overlooked groups”) are done because it is also used for these groups that have so far hardly been reached through educational offerings. By this we mean in particular children and young people with different, challenging life situations and educational histories. We focus on MINT offerings and look at how and in which places these target group(s) can be reached. In the second part The article is about the role of the easy-to-ignore groups in the work of zdi.NRW: Who are the groups that we are not yet reaching with our STEM offers and how can we change this? In the third part we show approaches and practical examples of how outreach MINT education can succeed in the zdi context and which steps will be necessary for this.

You can download the full text as a PDF here:

What does "easy-to-ignore" mean and who are the young people we easily overlook?

The term “easy-to-ignore” (loosely translated as “easy to overlook”) is mainly found in English-speaking countries. There it is not only used in an educational context. Rather, the term refers to inequalities in society as a whole. In general terms, “easy-to-ignore” groups are those whose potential can be easily overlooked due to their life situation. This leads to a reduction in participation and more difficult access to public funding and offers. The respective life situation is characterized by various dimensions such as access to education, self-confidence, resources (finances, time, capacities) and language. These dimensions create barriers that often make these groups invisible to educational actors, i.e. “easy to overlook”. The responsibility to take a closer look and do something about this oversight lies with those involved in education: within and not with the groups themselves, who are already experiencing limitations due to the respective barriers.

zdi.NRW focuses on the following so-called easy-to-ignore groups:

  • Those who have not yet found access to extracurricular MINT education for a variety of reasons, from the challenging life situation to their individual educational history.
  • Those who are struggling with obstacles and cannot stand up for themselves.
  • Those who are underrepresented in STEM educational offerings.

Where does the term come from?

The photo shows two bridges in the Scottish council area of ​​Fife. You can see the graphic outline of Fife, in which the rainbow colors contain symbols for different areas of society, such as old and young, a person in a wheelchair, a pregnant woman, praying hands...

Photo: Fife Centers for Equalities

The Scottish "Fife Center for Equalities“ helped coin the term “easy-to-ignore” groups.[1] The charity was founded in 2014 and campaigns for diversity and inclusion in many areas of society in the Scottish Council Area (state) Fife. The organization defines “easy-to-ignore” groups as groups that lack the capacity to participate in society and are therefore underrepresented in certain contexts. This usually includes people who are affected by at least one dimension of discrimination (racism, ableism, sexism, age discrimination...). Accordingly, identity and interest groups are also included. The Covid pandemic has also created new barriers by relying more on digital strategies, which were (and are) not equally accessible to everyone.

Terms in German-speaking research and educational work

In German-speaking research and educational work there has been little talk of “easy-to-ignore” groups. However, there are various concepts and terms that deal with so-called “educationally disadvantaged young people”. It is important to note that these terms may be used differently in different contexts. They serve to draw attention to the causes of existing educational inequalities and to develop measures to improve equal opportunities and access to education for all young people. At the same time, these terms always carry the risk of having a stigmatizing effect, which is why the terms often change in this area in particular.

The image has a decorative function. It stands symbolically for the term controller.

educational disadvantage

In this context, for example, educational disadvantage spoken. This term generally refers to structural inequalities that affect access to the education system, where certain groups of young people (or adults for that matter) have less access to education and related opportunities compared to others[2]. Educational disadvantage can be traced back to different dimensions.

The image has a decorative function. It is symbolic of the term map.

educational distance

One of these dimensions can be a so-called educational distance the social environment (primarily the family). However, this term is not used unequivocally and can be understood in different ways[3]. The term educational distance is sometimes used to express a distance from formal higher education resulting from a lack of proof of knowledge. Distance from education can also be understood as a position from which access to education is denied and the educational opportunities are therefore far away. The term can also be misunderstood to suggest that people affected by this dimension would actively stay away from educational opportunities.

The image has a decorative function. It symbolizes the concept of development.

poor education

Also the dimension of poor education as a term can be misleading. What is meant is, according to the definition of the sociologist Prof. Dr. Jutta Allmendinger, a poverty of educational certificates and educational skills[4]. But the term is also used to describe a situation where people have little or no access to education due to financial limitations and lack of resources. According to this understanding, educational poverty affects various aspects, such as a lack of learning materials, an inadequate learning environment or limited financial support for educational activities.

Both dimensions play into the factor of Secondary Origin Effects[5] in. These come into effect at the transition to secondary school and describe how the respective social background of the family affects the choice and access to secondary school.

The image has a decorative function. It symbolizes the concept of presentation.

(special educational) needs

Another dimension, which in turn is divided into different areas, is the (special educational) needs. In Germany, this is defined as an impairment of educational, developmental and learning opportunities, which means that adequate support is not possible without special educational support[6]. Educational disadvantages of this dimension arise when the required support is lacking, be it due to too few (appropriately trained) staff, due to unsuitable teaching material or the format of the offer, and much more. The definition of need for support had to face a lot of criticism when it came up. Above all, the formal consequences of assigning a need for support, namely the change to or enrollment in a special needs school, are questioned and criticized. [7]

The image has a decorative function. It is symbolic of the term arrow.

intersectionality

The dimensions of educational disadvantage also play a role intersectionality a role. For example, people with disabilities in Germany are more likely to be affected by poverty[8]. Children and young people of parents with a low level of education (according to the terminology above, children from families with little or no education) are more often at risk of poverty or social exclusion. According to the Federal Statistical Office, almost every fourth person under the age of 2022 was exposed to this threat in Germany in 18.[9]

The image has a decorative function. It is symbolic of the term levels. It shows three layers of white layers on top of each other on a dark blue background.

of life

Also in the aspect of of life different factors play into it. Life situations mean the interaction of, for example, socio-demographic, socio-economic, geographical and economic factors. The extent to which these factors actually affect access to education has yet to be shown varies from person to person. The zdi practice has shown, for example, that in large, rural regions, visiting extracurricular learning locations is made more difficult due to poorer accessibility. Or that the economic structure of a region with a focus on technical, manufacturing industries makes it easier to work with companies in the field of extracurricular STEM education compared to regions with a higher number of companies with a service focus. Just as the socio-demographic composition at a school can affect educational opportunities and participation in them - regardless of the type of school.

Since the terms used in German-language discourse have their pitfalls as described above, we in the zdi community would like to use the English-language term easy-to-ignore groups, which we translate in German as “easy-to-overlook groups”. This term makes it clearer who is responsible for equitable and empowering MINT education: not the group we want to reach, but us, the MINT actors!


Note: This contribution represents a working status and not the conclusion of a discussion. Rather, it shows a level of development and an approach to certain terms and forms the basis for further steps in the MINT educational work of the zdi community with certain target groups.  

Revision January 2024: In exchange with the zdi community, we have decided to use the term “overlook” instead of “ignore” in German in the future. This makes it clearer that the easy-to-ignore groups are not intentionally “ignored”, but are more often “overlooked” due to structural deficits in our society. We have therefore revised the article in the relevant places.

Continue to Part 2 - Which groups are currently often overlooked in the zdi context?

If you have any questions about the topic or the offers in the area of ​​outreach MINT education/zdi-BSO-MINT-Lab, please contact:

Consultation:

Communication:

Kerstin Helmerdig

Katharina Glowalla

Katharina Glowalla


[1] “Engaging with EASY-TO-IGNORE communities”, ed. Fife Center for Equalities, March 2021; https://centreforequalities.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/EASY-TO-IGNORE-GUIDE-Mar-2021.pdf (accessed on 19.07.2023)

[2] "Equal opportunities between claim and reality", published by the Federal Agency for Civic Education, authors: Wulf Hopf, Benjamin Gemstone, published on September 12.09.2018th, XNUMX: https://www.bpb.de/themen/bildung/dossier-bildung/174634/chancengleichheit-zwischen-anspruch-und-wirklichkeit/ (accessed on 24.07.2023)

[3] "The term Bildungsferne", ed. Wegweiser Bürgergesellschaft, a project of the Stiftung Mitarbeit, author: Tabea Witt: https://www.buergergesellschaft.de/praxishilfen/sozialraumorientierte-interkulturelle-arbeit/die-zugrunde-liegende-forschung/der-begriff-der-bildungsferne#alles-auf-einer-seite (accessed on 24.07.2023)

[4] "Educational poverty", published by the Federal Agency for Civic Education in the magazine "Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte", authors: Jutta Allmendinger, Stephan Leibfried, published on May 28.05.2003, XNUMX: https://www.bpb.de/shop/zeitschriften/apuz/27619/bildungsarmut/ (accessed on 24.07.2023)

[5]   "Causes of educational inequalities" published by the Federal Agency for Civic Education, author: Kai Maaz, published on December 08.12.2020th, XNUMX:  https://www.bpb.de/themen/bildung/dossier-bildung/322528/ursachen-von-bildungsungleichheiten/ (accessed on 24.07.2023)

[6]  "The education system in the Federal Republic of Germany 2017/2018. Presentation of the competencies, structures and educational policy developments for the exchange of information in Europe.", Chapter "Educational support and advice", paragraph 12.2, p. 264, Kultusministerkonferenz 2019, in cooperation with the German EURYDICE information center of the federal government at the Federal Ministry of Education and Research , Berlin, 2019: https://www.kmk.org/dokumentation-statistik/informationen-zum-deutschen-bildungssystem/dossier-deutsch.html (accessed on 24.07.2023)

[7] "Special educational needs", Section 2: Definition of terms; Published socialnet lexicon, author: Prof. Dr. Gwendolin Bartz, published on 31.08.2022/XNUMX/XNUMX: https://www.socialnet.de/lexikon/Sonderpaedagogischer-Foerderbedarf (accessed on 24.07.2023)

[8] "Third participation report by the federal government on the living conditions of people with disabilities", published by the Federal Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs, Bonn, April 2021, Section 5: Employment and material living situation; https://www.bmas.de/DE/Service/Publikationen/Broschueren/a125-21-teilhabebericht.html (accessed on 24.07.2023)

[9] "Children and young people of parents with low educational qualifications are particularly at risk of poverty - press release no. N045", Federal Statistical Office, published on July 26.07.2023, XNUMX: https://www.destatis.de/DE/Presse/Pressemitteilungen/2023/07/PD23_N045_63.html (accessed on 26.07.2023)

You might also be interested in these posts

The graphic shows the logo for the zdi robot competition 2024. It shows the motto "Smart Cities - Cities as a living space of the future" and a robot and a dinosaur that are building an intelligent city together.

General, robot competition

zdi robot competition 2024: Local competitions completed – participants for regional rounds have been determined

A woman puts on a VR headset at the public exhibition “Future Day 2024”. She interacts with a virtual reality simulation that recreates the interior of a train.

General, girls promotion

Get young people excited about MINT at Future Day 2024

In a modern atrium, a group of experts presents zdi quality seal certificates. They stand offset from each other and a staircase can be seen in the background.

General

zdi quality seal handover in the state parliament of North Rhine-Westphalia